Do not stand for this flagrant abuse of our farcical democracy!
Megaupload has been forcibly closed by the FBI. In a sickening undermining of the people’s will, they are making an example out of an historic, legitimate, useful and well-known website. This is a prophetic glimmer of the coming war against pure free speech- the internet.
This happened once before. Here in the UK, the IWF (Internet Watch Foundation) is a censoring system for the internet. In 1996, the Metropolitan Police started requesting the banning of illegal content by ISPs in the UK. With veiled sly threats they asked that ISPs engage in ‘self-enforcement’ rather than forcing them to enforce the law on them.
Most of the ISPs complied except Demon internet. Demon was a British ISP that contributed to the Open Source community, ran several IRC servers and were pioneers of their time. They objected on the grounds of it being “unacceptable censorship”. A few days later, a tabloid expose appeared in the Observer newspaper alleging that the director of Demon was supplying paedophiles with photographs of children being sexually abused.
Then the police let it be known that during that summer, they were planning a crack-down on an unspecified ISP as a test-case (translation: making an example of them). Between the threats and pressure, the IWF was formed- a supposedly voluntary organisation but in fact a fake-charity and a quango. The IWF is a disgraceful secretive group with an awful corrupt history and no public oversight.
Now we see the same tactic has been used against Megaupload. They are using the threat of violence to coerce companies, how the British police did to create their own laws. The SOPA legislation did not go their way, so they have resulted to immoral tactics of repression.
From ACTA which is decided behind closed European chambers, the DEA which was pushed through undemocratically at alarming speed before elections, evil La Hadopi and now SOPA/PIPA in the US, there is nowhere to run. The nepotists are determined to push through these legislation. At all costs. This is not about piracy- it never was and will not do a thing. It is about control.
We have built a tool. For all their false talk of democracy we have for the first time in history reached this epochal moment. Self determination. If they truly believed in democracy, we could have a direct-democracy tomorrow. The tools exist. Instead we see this flagrant deception. It has become acceptable for politicians to cater to the greatest common denominator. We let them off the hook on the truth like Cameron pretending to be pro-NHS or Obama pretending to be Christian because it is for voters. Since when did it become acceptable to lie! Now today we see this limp-wristed hand wringing by the US president about how he will veto SOPA. Oh shut up.
Was it Gordan Brown who said that voting levels were dangerously low in the below-30s because youngsters today are apolitical. He wanted mandatory attendance for voters. No, we are not apolitical, we are sick of your lies and deceit. This generation is probably more political than any generation in history. In the 80s, only 5% of people in the US were members of organisations. In the 90s, 70% of Americans belonged to some kind of organisation. People are mobilising and prescient of issues.
Libel law is atrociously bad in the UK. Payouts are 100 times greater than in main-land Europe and you get a situation where billionaires use law firms like Carter-Ruck to keep news publishers (which are poor) in court and bleed them dry. Time magazine did an undercover piece of reporting and was sued for libel. They won the case but it ended up costing them $1 million. That’s effectively a fine of $1 million for undercover journalism.
Of course when the law is broken, what do we do? Make more laws! That is why California has brought in anti-SLAPP legislation.
Patent law is so stupid and I won’t even go there.
Copyright is fascist. I find it revolting that we are creating this artificial scarcity where there is none. Everyone could have the Alexandrian library in their back-pocket. It is not the responsibility of these new models to bail out the old ones. The wealth of world knowledge harnessed by parasites.
The biggest copyright lobbyists have their own origins in the bootleg and parody industries. Fox moved west to escape litigious action by Edison’s copyrights. Disney’s original Mickey Mouse cartoons were rip-offs of The Jazz Singer and Buster Keaton’s Steamboat Bill Jr. In fact nearly ever Disney film is a rip-off from popular culture: Mulan, Cinderella, Jungle Book, Little Mermaid, Tarzan, … Yet the constant copyright extensions right before it expires for Mickey Mouse has become a twisted joke- termed the Mickey Mouse Copyright Extensions.
Copyright’s own origin is in the 1700s when the English protectorate wanted to protect London publishers from Scottish ones who were printing public domain work. It was a monopolistic law. How then has society somehow brainwashed itself into believing they are anything but? We have the copyright owners for “I have a dream” issuing DMCA takedowns against websites. This is an important historical document- how can copyright be encouraging artists to create when they are DEAD.
This does not have much to do with bitcoin, but I am mad. This free-speech infringement feels so odious and Machiavellian that you cannot stand it, and the only way to stop the machine is to throw yourself under the tracks. The vox populi means nothing under the false pretense of ‘protecting artists’.
If downloading child pornography supports child pornographers how can downloading music destroy the music industry?


I’m pretty angry.
Your anger is understandable, Amir. We’re all pretty angry about it. But that’s not enough. Governments don’t care if you’re angry as long as you obey and bow down. The time has come for us to stop obeying and stop bowing down. Do more than be angry: take action. Channel your anger into action.
LOL UMAD SON?
But really, great article. You are 100% bang on the money when you say its not about the money, its control…..i realised this myself a few years ago. The internet scares the SHIT out of them.
Don’t take it personally but if there is any site that should fall under SOPA its this site. All of all sites these types are the worst.
based on…..? dont you get what internet is for?
Based on the fact they blatantly promote illegal movies ? etc. etc. The Internet isn’t for you to be an anarchist and have free willing power you realize this right? Look my point is this is the last website you should be standing up for there are plenty of websites that deserve protection this isn’t one of them.
It was a bit of an angry article. Not terribly balanced…
You should write a second one in a more calm neutral style. Opinion articles are great and all, but people should make their own opinions.
Even still, I do agree with just about everything you said.
HE’S MAD BRO.
Lets not make this usual, but I *really* had to vent. It’s not often I feel this mad. The timing of this closure was flippant and almost provocative like look what we can do and nobody can stop us.
A 76 page indictment with child pornography and terrorism thrown in. Remember when they come for the net they will use the four horseman of the infocalypse.
Yup, I’m mad too. I’m about ready to kick off.
It makes me mad too but when you say “look what we can do and nobody can stop us” it makes me imagine how other people could start up 10 more similar sites within 24 hours and say “yes, but look what WE can do”.
OK… please, PLEASE add a Facebook share button to your site so people can click to share this article!
+1
Simply copy paste
Everything here is Creative Commons (see bottom of the page).
I WANT you to copy these works… Remix them…
Link to indictment: http://www.slideshare.net/freakyseba/78786408-megaindictment
Actually they didn’t take them down for simply “copyright” issues, but how much is true is another story, but long story short.
-They went to sites dedicated to collecting links for copyrighted material and offered to advertise on them.
-They told people HOW TO FIND COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL ON THEIR SITE.
-They made a fake top 100 list to look more legitimate.
-The MD5 Removal system they implemented was subpar, because if multiple links were made of the same thing, it became absolutely useless for someone who wanted their copyrighted stuff taken down.
-they were told by copyright holders to take down 39 different files that infringed copyright, and in the span of a year, only removed three.
-Van Der Kolk, one of the accused, was paid $55 THOUSAND DOLLARS for uploading copyrighted material to them. Even exchanging emails with them. The people who oversaw it KNEW it was illegal, and yet they put it up anyway.
and that’s that.
The mafia boss finds the lowest hanging fruit (the easiest picking) and smashes up the shop. Then he tells the other shop owners to pay up to his protection racket.
Considering the timing right before the planned SOPA bill, I’d say this was a planned conspiracy. A double whammy of legislature (SOPA/PIPA) and enforcement by making an example of Megaupload to get sites to comply.
The UK’s Metropolitan Police used this same tactic in 1996 to write their own laws. Now we see the FBI working with the government to force the internet to toe the line through repression. They are pulling out all the stops here. They are making an example of Megaupload to induce fear.
This is wrong no matter how they spin it. The shysters and goons are out in force.
More likely it’s to show that they don’t need SOPA/PIPA as in “look we can just take down sites using existing laws”. It’s like a peace offering to the media cartels to keep them happy when they fail to implement SOPA/PIPA (as I suspect was always their plan).
So if I report a MD5 hash of my copyrighted work to a company like Megaupload they should delete that file from everyones accounts?
So what do you do about someone who is storing a backup of this file on Megaupload, delete it?
You can’t just use a MD5 hash and delete anything matching that hash, it has to be a URL and a MD5.
Can you give 2 data sets that produce the same md5 hash?
fascinating times we live in. i for one am grateful that i live in an age of burgeoning fascism. it is simply amazing to watch. better than anything hollywood could actually put on celluloid.
We all need to be a little more grateful to the americans for putting on such a bravura display of jack booted idiocy. rare indeed is such a chance to live through the important bits of history. treasure these days.
I agree that this attack on Megaupload is despicable, but why is it NOT OK for the Feds to go after Megaupload, but OK for them to regulate Bitcoin?
You cannot be simulatneously FOR the government regulating things on the internet and at the same time, AGAINST them shutting down Megaupload, AND be consistent.
The really good answer would be to invent a new business model that could make the copyright protection itself obsolete. That could be more affective than a thousand protests.
@Zell Faze
Its his site, he can write in whatever style he likes. Forget the ‘should’ stuff.
I got no problems with copyright. If you made the work you should be able to sell it. Patents on the other hand, especially recent software patents, stop you writting your own work. It’s like saying Ian Flemming, the creator of James Bond, has 20 years monopoly on writing spy novels.
Nobody stops you if you want to sell your work. What is unacceptable is to point guns at people in order to sell your work.
Copyright and Patent lawsuits are one thing, it’s another that these groups have lobbied congress to use force against their violations at the expense of the common tax payer.
Let them file civil lawsuits, criminal cases should only deal with acts of violence.
Free flow of information is the only safeguard against tyranny.
Alex Jones had his own rant out today titled “The Great Internet War Has Begun”. http://www.infowars.com/the-great-internet-wars-have-begun/
Looks like you aren’t the only angry person out there. Where are good places to learn more about P2P decentralized internet systems, and what are the most successful projects to date?
I liked this article despite its imperfections and support Amir/his work the way I can. Unfortunately being angry does not do much and there is no point to pretend that sites like megaupload can go off like candles by whatever government’s will. It is all down to money in the end of the day, as always. If community is supportive enough to donate enough bitcoins/etc. to resurrect it – it will happen. It is even quite possible to appeal and contest US government for damages once the funds allow it. First, however, we must be sure that megaupload’s owners did not make a deal to ‘go down’ for whatever reason, financial or otherwise and that is the main point in this discussion. Corrupt government can only be a product of a corrupt society, call it whatever you choose but when kids rob supermarkets just because they’re given a chance surely your next government will be even worse.
They should have definitely had a day in court before just shutting everything down and seizing property.
But read this article, its a good read:
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2012/01/mega-man-the-bizarre-rise-and-sudden-downfall-of-kim-dotcom.ars
After reading that it makes you happy their business is being busted.
Amir, the text in this post is beautiful. Very well put!
Thanks. Makes me really happy.
well the only conspirators visible is the F.BI…what dickheads these americans…trying their useless laws on the world…rogues in police uniform
technically the FBI have no jurisdiction in New Zealand. The tactics they’ve used by storming in to a private property with several teams of the Armed Defenders Squad goes to show the deep paranoia the spooks foster on their own people. NZ is not under American jurisdiction. Currently the Crown is dragging its feet much to the annoyance to the FBI. The FBI wanted to extradite (kidnap) the founders and employees of Megaupload the same day as the raid, but the Crown works differently as they have had no time to prepare any kind of case, defense or otherwise. The problem is that Extradition gets paid by the taxpayer of the host country in question, so the Feds are so tight they don’t even pay for their own expenditure. Getting back to why the FBI is out of their jurisdiction, unless some obscure law change has happened in the New World Order the Feds are an internal Federal Reserve enforcement agency. Which means the US dollar that gets distributed on American soil ONLY. Since the US put their nose in Vietnam, Korea, Panama, Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and now Iran, they now want to bully the rebellious kiwis. As far as I know the only treaty that NZ has with the US is ANZAC… and the US is not even mentioned in the acronym. The US withdrew from their ANZAC obligation because of NZs nuclear stance. What laws has Megaupload broken in New Zealand is the question the Crown wants answered. The Extradition hearing is quite soon.